18 November 2026 · Blog · Manuel Nuber CEO

Is selling options risky? What can go wrong and how professionals manage it

Selling options earns steady premium and can cause large losses. Which structures carry which risk, two real blow-ups, and how professionals size and hedge.

Yes. Selling options earns small, frequent gains and exposes you to occasional large losses. How risky it is depends on two things: the structure (whether your maximum loss is capped) and the size (how much of your capital a bad week can take). Most famous blow-ups combined uncapped structures with too much leverage.

Key points

  • An option seller's best case is the premium; the worst case can be many times larger.
  • Uncovered calls have unlimited risk; spreads cap the loss in advance.
  • Leverage, not the option itself, is what usually turns losses into wipe-outs.
  • Losses cluster in sudden market shocks, when prices gap and volatility jumps together.
  • Sizing, defined-risk structures and pre-agreed rules are the main defences.

Why option selling feels safe until it isn't

Most options expire worthless, so a seller wins most of the time. That builds confidence, and often size. The loss distribution is lopsided: many small wins and a few very large losses. Statisticians call this negative skew. One bad week can erase years of premium, and it tends to arrive exactly when markets are in turmoil and adjusting is hardest.

Not all option selling is equally risky

Structure

Maximum loss

Leverage

In plain words

Uncovered call

Unlimited

Margin account

The most dangerous position in options

Uncovered put on margin

Strike minus premium, per contract, on capital you may not hold

Margin account

Losses can exceed the money set aside

Cash-secured put

Strike minus premium, fully funded

None

Like owning the shares below the strike

Covered call

Fall in the shares minus premium

None

The risk sits in the shares, not the call

Credit spread

Strike gap minus premium

Margin equals the maximum loss

Worst case known in advance

Illustrative example: capping the worst case

Hypothetical numbers for illustration only. An index trades at 100. Instead of selling a 95 put on its own, you sell the 95 put and buy the 90 put, receiving a net 1.00 per share (€100 per contract).

  • Index stays above 95: both expire worthless and you keep €100.
  • Index falls to 80: the sold put loses €1,500, the bought put gains €1,000. Your loss is capped at €400 (€500 gap minus the €100 premium).
  • The 95 put on its own, sold for, say, 1.50, would have lost €1,350 at 80, and more the further the index fell.

The spread earns less in good months, but you know the worst case before you trade.

How would your portfolio hold up in a crash? Rivativ Risk runs crash scenarios on your own holdings, so you decide on data, not gut feeling. Free forever, no credit card required.

Two real blow-ups, and what they teach

February 2018: the short-volatility note. XIV, an exchange-traded note that profited when volatility fell, lost 96.3% of its value on 5 February 2018 as the VIX spiked; its value dropped from $115.55 to $4.22 in one day, and the issuer, Credit Suisse, shut it down. XIV held VIX futures rather than options, but the exposure was the same: short volatility, with no cap on the loss. Lesson: a strategy that wins steadily in calm markets can lose almost everything in one day.

November 2018: OptionSellers.com. A US firm sold strangles (uncovered calls and puts) on commodity futures for around 290 clients. When natural gas prices jumped in mid-November, the short calls were liquidated, and clients lost more than 100% of their accounts, leaving some owing money to their broker. Lesson: uncovered calls plus leverage plus concentration in one market is how option sellers lose more than they have.

How professionals manage the risk

  1. Size for the worst case, not the premium. Decide how much a crash may cost the portfolio, then size the position so that limit holds.
  2. Prefer defined-risk structures. Spreads, or puts that are fully cash-secured, keep the worst case known.
  3. Avoid uncovered calls. Their loss is unlimited.
  4. Hold protection that gains in a shock, such as long puts or volatility hedges, so the book does not depend on calm markets.
  5. Respect the volatility regime. High premiums usually mean high risk; they are not a signal to sell more.
  6. Write the rules before the trade: when to reduce, when to close, what happens on a gap.

How Rivativ helps you manage option risk

Rivativ is software for your own decisions. Risk shows what a crash scenario, a gap or a volatility spike would do to your whole portfolio, including any options you hold. The Strategies builder lets you compare an uncovered position with a defined-risk version and see the worst case before you trade, and Radar gives you market odds and alerts when the volatility regime shifts. An AI assistant explains every number in plain English. Example strategies in Rivativ show how the tools work; they are not recommendations to follow.

Invest on data and logic, not gut feeling. Rivativ shows you market odds and alerts, how your own portfolio would hold up in a crash, and options strategies for income or protection, all explained in plain language by an AI assistant. Free forever, no credit card required.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment, tax or legal advice, nor a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to use any strategy. Options involve significant risk and are not suitable for every investor; you can lose more than the premium received. Examples are hypothetical. Past performance and backtests are not reliable indicators of future results.

← News and analysis

Questions

Is selling options risky?

Yes. It earns small, frequent gains and exposes you to occasional large losses. The structure and the size of the position decide how large those losses can be.

Can you lose more than you invest when selling options?

Yes, with uncovered calls or uncovered positions on margin. Cash-secured puts, covered calls and credit spreads have a defined worst case.

Is selling puts safer than buying shares?

A cash-secured put has a similar downside to owning the shares from the strike price down, cushioned by the premium. It earns less in a strong rally, because the gain is capped at the premium.

What is the safest way to sell options?

Defined-risk structures such as credit spreads or fully cash-secured puts, sized so that a severe crash stays within a loss you can accept.

Why do option sellers blow up?

Usually through a combination of uncovered positions, leverage and concentration, hit by a sudden market shock in which prices gap and volatility jumps together.