A collar combines a protective put with a covered call on the same holding: you buy a put below the market and sell a call above it. The call premium pays for some or all of the put, so your position is locked into a range. Losses below the put strike are covered, and gains above the call strike are given away.
Key points
- A collar sets both a floor and a ceiling on your position until expiry.
- A "zero-cost" collar costs no premium, but you pay with upside instead of cash.
- It is cheaper than buying puts alone and much more defensive than holding the shares unprotected.
- Long-term index data shows collars cut volatility a lot but also cut returns, by more than the reduction in risk.
- Collars suit a known risk window or a position you cannot afford to lose, not permanent use.
How a collar works
You hold a position and add two options:
- Buy a put below the current price, which sets the floor.
- Sell a call above the current price, which sets the ceiling and pays for the put.
Illustrative example
Hypothetical numbers for illustration only. You hold an index position worth €10,000 at a level of 100. You buy a put with a strike of 95 for 1.50 and sell a call with a strike of 110 for 1.50. The net premium is zero.
Index at expiry | Position alone | With collar |
|---|---|---|
120 | +€2,000 | +€1,000 (capped at 110) |
110 | +€1,000 | +€1,000 |
100 | €0 | €0 |
90 | −€1,000 | −€500 (floor at 95) |
70 | −€3,000 | −€500 (floor at 95) |
Until expiry, your result is locked between −€500 and +€1,000, whatever the market does.
Use options with confidence. The Rivativ Strategies builder lets you design options strategies for income and protection on your own portfolio, with an AI assistant that explains every step. Free forever, no credit card required.
"Zero-cost" is not free
A collar with no net premium still has a price: every euro the market rises above the call strike goes to the buyer of your call. Over time, equity markets earn much of their return in a minority of strong months, and those are exactly the months a collar gives away.
There is a second, quieter cost. Index puts are usually priced richly, because institutions must buy protection, while out-of-the-money calls tend to be priced less richly. A collar buys the expensive option and sells the cheaper one, so on average it pays away part of the volatility risk premium rather than earning it.
What the long-term data shows
Cboe's S&P 500 95-110 Collar Index (CLL) holds the S&P 500, buys quarterly puts 5% below the market and sells monthly calls 10% above it. A December 2016 paper by Roni Israelov and Matthew Klein, Risk and Return of Equity Index Collars, found that from July 1986 to December 2014 CLL earned 3.2% a year above cash, against 7.3% for the S&P 500. Its volatility was 10.7% against 15.7%, and its Sharpe ratio 0.30 against 0.47. In short: a collar reliably lowers risk, but it has historically cut returns by more than it cut risk.
Newer data on a different collar design points the same way. Cboe's S&P 500 Zero-Cost Put Spread Collar Index (CLLZ) buys a put 2.5% below the market, sells one 5% below and sells a call that pays for both, every month. From July 1986 to September 2021 it returned 7.65% a year against 10.83% for the S&P 500, with volatility of 11.7% against 15.2%. Its worst drawdown was −43.0% against −50.9%. The cheaper put spread leaves the crash tail uncovered, so its drawdown sits much closer to the index than a full collar's.
Design choices matter. A 2021 study comparing fourteen collar and protective-put variants over 2008–2016 found that a protective put and a zero-cost collar with both strikes 2% out of the money performed best among them, and that collars carried more risk in bullish periods.
Collar vs other ways to protect
Protective put | Collar | Put spread collar | |
|---|---|---|---|
How it works | Buy a put | Buy a put, sell a call | Buy a put spread, sell a call |
Cost | Premium every period | Around zero | Around zero |
Downside | Floor at the put strike | Floor at the put strike | Covered only between the two put strikes |
Upside | Full, minus premium | Capped at the call strike | Capped at the call strike, usually higher than in a collar |
Best for | Short, known risk windows | Locking in a range for a while | Cushioning moderate falls cheaply |
Collars for investors in Europe
You can collar a UCITS ETF with options on the index it tracks. The bought put needs no margin. The sold call is the part to check: brokers with risk-based margin recognise the ETF as an offset, while others treat the call as uncovered and require full margin.
Risks: how a collar costs you
- Missed rallies. Gains above the call strike go to someone else, often in the best months.
- Paying the premium twice. You buy rich puts and sell cheaper calls, which tends to cost return over time.
- Short protection. The floor only lasts until expiry; rolling it is a new decision each time.
- Margin on the call. Depending on your broker, a strong rally can trigger margin calls on the sold call.
How Rivativ helps with collars
The Rivativ Strategies builder lets you set up a collar on your own holdings and compare it with a protective put or a put spread collar, including where the floor and ceiling sit and what each gives up. Risk shows how your portfolio would behave in crash scenarios with and without the collar, and Radar gives you market odds and alerts when the volatility regime shifts. An AI assistant explains every leg in plain English. Example strategies in Rivativ show how the tools work; they are not recommendations to follow.
Invest on data and logic, not gut feeling. Rivativ shows you market odds and alerts, how your own portfolio would hold up in a crash, and options strategies for income or protection, all explained in plain language by an AI assistant. Free forever, no credit card required.
Related reading
- Protective puts explained
- Covered calls explained
- Options strategies explained: which one for which goal
- The volatility risk premium explained
This article is for educational purposes only and is not investment, tax or legal advice, nor a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to use any strategy. Options involve significant risk and are not suitable for every investor; you can lose more than the premium received. Examples are hypothetical. Past performance and backtests are not reliable indicators of future results.